The social context of
historical understanding: Recent research findings from the United States
Keith C. Barton Associate Professor, University
of CincinnatiVisiting Fellow, University of Ulster, Coleraine
Over the last fifteen years,
cognitive theorists and researchers have begun to take seriously
a perspective long familiar to anthropologists and other social
theorists-that social and cultural factors significantly influence
human thought and learning. Usually referred to as situated cognition
or situated learning, this approach emphasises that thinking does
not take place solely "inside the head" but is in large
part determined by social context-particularly the social settings
in which people learn and the culturally defined purposes which
guide their learning. (See, for example, Lave and Wenger, 1991;
Rogoff, 1990, 1984.) This perspective has important implications
for educators: If we hope to understand children's historical thinking
we cannot limit ourselves to observing whether they have masteredt
he content of the school curriculum or whether they think like historians,
for it may be other settings and other purposes which have a more
profound impact on their understanding. In order to plan and implement
effective instruction, then, teachers and curriculum planners must
take into account the social settings which guide children's learning
about the past. This paper summarises the results of three recent
studies in the United States which shed light on how students' understanding
is shaped by the larger society of which they are a part.
|